Bottled water is among the most successful marketing stories of the late twentieth century. In 1975, Americans drank essentially no commercially bottled water. By 2008, when Elizabeth Royte published Bottlemania, the United States was the world's largest bottled water market. How did this happen? And what are the environmental, political, and cultural consequences of treating water as a commodity?
What Is This Book?
Royte’s investigation moves between three levels. The first is journalistic — she traces the origins of a specific Nestlé water-bottling operation in Maine and the community resistance it provoked. The second is cultural — she asks how corporate marketing convinced millions of people to pay a thousand times the cost of tap water for something often drawn from municipal supplies. The third is environmental — she documents the plastic waste, energy cost, and groundwater depletion that the bottled water industry generates.
The book is funny, sharp, and occasionally infuriating — which is exactly the right tone for its subject.
The Poland Spring Investigation
The Maine chapters are the heart of the book. Nestlé’s Poland Spring operation draws water from local aquifers and sells it nationally, while the communities around the springs watch their water tables drop and fight, mostly unsuccessfully, for meaningful oversight of extraction rates. The regulatory framework governing groundwater extraction in most American states is, as Royte documents, essentially non-existent.
We've created a system where corporations can profit from a public resource, externalise the environmental costs onto communities and ecosystems, and face essentially no meaningful regulatory oversight. Bottled water is the template for this model, not the exception.
— Elizabeth Royte, Bottlemania
The Tap Water Case
Royte makes a rigorous case for tap water. Municipal water supplies in developed countries are tested far more frequently and to higher standards than bottled water. The taste difference that consumers cite is largely a product of marketing psychology and, where real, is fixable with a simple filter. The environmental cost of bottled water — plastic, transport, refrigeration — is orders of magnitude greater than tap per unit of water delivered.
6 Key Ideas From This Book
The bottled water industry grew by creating anxiety about tap water safety — anxiety that, in most developed countries, is not supported by the evidence.
Municipal water is tested hundreds of times per day. Bottled water is regulated as a food product with far less frequent testing and no requirement to disclose source or treatment method.
Corporations extracting groundwater for commercial sale are drawing on a shared resource with minimal compensation to the communities and ecosystems that depend on it.
The environmental footprint of producing, filling, transporting, and disposing of plastic water bottles dwarfs the ecological cost of delivering the same water through municipal infrastructure.
In communities where tap water is genuinely unsafe — Flint, Michigan being the most visible example — bottled water is not a lifestyle choice but a survival necessity. The industry profits from infrastructure failure.
The bottled water market is part of a broader movement to treat water as a tradeable commodity rather than a human right — with profound implications for equitable access.
Any Weaknesses?
The book is now over fifteen years old, and the bottled water market and plastic waste conversation have both evolved considerably since 2008. The rise of reusable water bottles and increasing awareness of microplastics are not addressed. Some sections feel slightly dated, and the regulatory analysis would benefit from updating. Royte is also primarily focused on the American context; the global water privatisation story is larger and more urgent than she addresses.
Who Should Read This?
Anyone who buys bottled water regularly and has never interrogated that choice — this book will change how you think about a habit most people have never examined.
Cadillac Desert for the larger water politics context, or Plastic Ocean for the downstream consequences of single-use plastic packaging.
Municipal water utility managers — Royte's analysis of how the bottled water industry benefits from public distrust of tap water is directly relevant to infrastructure investment and public communication strategy.
A book that is now somewhat dated on regulatory and market details. The core argument is as valid as ever, but some specifics need updating from current sources.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Bottlemania: How Water Went on Sale and Why We Bought It worth reading?
A sharp, well-reported investigation into one of consumer culture's most successful and least scrutinised habits. Royte's Maine investigation is particularly good, documenting the local consequences of corporate groundwater extraction with the specificity that national-level analysis rarely achieves. Buy a reusable bottle and read this book.
Who should read Bottlemania: How Water Went on Sale and Why We Bought It?
Anyone who buys bottled water regularly and has never interrogated that choice — this book will change how you think about a habit most people have never examined.
What is Bottlemania: How Water Went on Sale and Why We Bought It about in one sentence?
Bottled water is among the most successful marketing stories of the late twentieth century.
The Verdict
A sharp, well-reported investigation into one of consumer culture's most successful and least scrutinised habits. Royte's Maine investigation is particularly good, documenting the local consequences of corporate groundwater extraction with the specificity that national-level analysis rarely achieves. Buy a reusable bottle and read this book.
→ Find on Amazon